I received this book for free from Netgalley in order to prepare an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
On Second Thought by Kristan Higgins
Series: Cambry-on-Hudson #2
Published by HQN Books on January 31st 2017
FINAL DECISION: A book that focuses on two sisters experiencing the ending of the relationships and the birth of new ones, this book was interesting but the romance was definitely secondary.
THE STORY: Kate finally has everything she has ever wanted except a child. She and her new husband have been trying since their marriage and have hopes of having a child soon — then he husband dies in a freak accident on the night her stepsister expects to get engaged. Ainsley has been with her boyfriend for eleven years and expected to be with him forever — until the death of Kate’s husband convinces him to dump her. Now Kate and Ainsley are living together and their mutual grief and anger bring them together in a way they didn’t expect. Both also have other men in their lives step up and begin to develop a different romantic relationship.
OPINION: I’ll be honest with you, I’m not a fan of so-called “women’s fiction” because I prefer books where the romance is central to the story. While this book has romance (two of them) in it, I was left unsatisfied because I wanted to know more about the romance between the characters than either Kate or Ainsley’s personal journey.
That doesn’t mean the book wasn’t good. It was well written and I really did enjoy it, but I wouldn’t read it again. The central story in this book is Kate’s loss of her husband. Because the book begins before her husband’s death and takes her through her grieving process, her husband is a central part of the book. This is Kate’s journey and I greatly appreciated that her journey was complex and multifaceted and addressed head on how one lives again after a loss. The book was especially refreshing in that it doesn’t judge Kate for moving on — even if other do. It is all here..the grief, the anger, the denial, the desire to be normal and live again. The emotions are messy and much remains unresolved.
For me, however, the complexity of these emotions meant that they overshadowed any romance between her and Daniel. Things between them felt like default. I liked him and liked his character, but I didn’t feel any intensity between them. Instead, it felt like any guy who had been there for her would have garnered the same response from her. I walked away from the book wondering if the two would even be together in a couple of years.
I really liked the story of Ainsley more and I wish there had been more resolution to her story. Ainsley is suffering when her boyfriend of eleven years dumps her, but that event opens her up to the possibility of a different guy. I thought that her feelings for her ex were resolved before she got involved so the romance felt less conflicted and I really got some connection between these characters. Her romance was funny and sweet and my only wish is that I had gotten more.
This book is billed as two sisters who resolve their relationship. But there really isn’t much to resolve between these two. Yes, there was distance and the two were not particularly close, but there were no serious disagreements or problems between them. Rather than being their story, I felt that Kate’s personal journey was the heart of this story and Ainsley had a supporting role (even though the book is told in alternating first persons).
Ultimately, the book is a serious look at grief and loss and living again, but not my favorite kind of book. (I do want to note that I read Higgins previous book in this vein, IF YOU ONLY KNEW, and liked it much better).
WORTH MENTIONING: This book is really women’s fiction rather than romance although romance does play a part.
CONNECTED BOOKS: This book is loosely connected to IF YOU ONLY KNEW as the two take place in the same town, Cambry-on-Hudson.
STAR RATING: I give this book 3.5 stars.
NOTE: I received an ARC of this book via Netgalley in order to provide a review. I was not required to write a positive review. All opinions contained herein are my own.