FINAL DECISION: I’ve read this book before, and it has much better versions. It feels like it was cribbed from prior authors who pioneered the romance series. The book has some good moments but lacks emotion and depth in the characters and it left me cold.

THE STORY: The story centers on two main characters: Jack Mulligan, a self-made man who has risen from a difficult childhood on the Bowery to become a powerful figure in Manhattan’s underworld, and Justine Greene, an upper-class woman dedicated to social causes such as workers’ rights and holding negligent husbands accountable. The story examines the clash and eventual alignment of their worlds as they form an alliance that evolves into a romantic relationship.

OPINION: THE DEVIL OF DOWNTOWN presents an intriguing premise set against the backdrop of Gilded Age New York. The contrast between Jack Mulligan, a self-made criminal kingpin, and Justine Greene, an upper-class social reformer, initially promises a compelling exploration of class dynamics and unexpected romance. The historical setting and the clash of worlds between the protagonists set up what could have been a riveting narrative.

However, the execution falls short of its potential. The romance between Jack and Justine develops too rapidly, lacking the gradual build-up and tension that make such unlikely pairings captivating. Justine’s character, in particular, suffers from a lack of meaningful growth throughout the story. Her initial passion for social causes doesn’t evolve or deepen in ways that feel authentic or engaging, leaving her character feeling somewhat flat and predictable.

While the book does have its moments, particularly in its depiction of 19th-century New York and some of the social issues of the time, it ultimately fails to deliver the emotional depth and character complexity that the premise suggests. The narrative often feels formulaic, echoing plot points and character dynamics that readers of historical romance may find overly familiar. This sense of déjà vu detracts from the originality of the setting and initial concept.

WORTH MENTIONING: I suggest reading DREAMING OF YOU by Lisa Kleypas instead. Much better book.

CONNECTED BOOKS: THE DEVIL OF DOWNTOWN is the third book in the Uptown Grils series. This book can be read as a standalone. The couples for the prior books appear, but everything the reader needs to know is explained here. I haven’t read the other books in the series and didn’t need to.

STAR RATING: I give this book 3 stars.