
Series: Difficult Dukes #3
on January 21, 2025
Genres: Historical
Goodreads
FINAL DECISION: Chase delivers a nuanced exploration of romance that extends and challenges the traditional romance narrative, examining the complexities of building a lasting partnership. The vibrant characters and authentic portrayal of married life create a beautiful addition to the series.
THE STORY: For years, the Duke of Blackwood has been known as the most sensible of Their Dis-Graces, the notorious trio of dukes whose escapades have scandalized London society. When Alice Ripley, sister to one of his fellow dukes, decides to enter the marriage market out of concern for her family’s future, Blackwood finds himself drawn into her orbit. His stated purpose may be protecting her from unsuitable suitors, but as Alice’s passionate pursuit of justice leads them into one situation after another, he discovers that maintaining his careful distance has become impossible. Their tale unfolds across two timelines, revealing both their path to marriage and the challenges they face in the year that follows.
OPINION: Chase tackles the ambitious task of telling a story that serves multiple narrative purposes while still delivering a satisfying romance. By structuring the novel across two distinct periods, she illuminates not just the thrill of falling in love but the day-to-day reality of living a married life.
The chemistry between Alice and Blackwood manifests in sharp-witted exchanges and unspoken understanding. Their shared history provides depth to their interactions, while their individual growth shows how two people can maintain their distinct personalities while building a life together. Alice stands out as a compelling protagonist whose convictions drive the narrative forward, while Blackwood’s gradual acknowledgment of his feelings unfolds with satisfying inevitability.
Though the novel’s unique structure creates occasional pacing issues, particularly in the transition between its two main sections, the rewards of this unconventional approach outweigh its drawbacks. Chase excels at period detail, weaving historical elements seamlessly into the narrative fabric without sacrificing momentum or emotional impact.
Memorable scenes abound, from intimate moments of realization to grander set pieces involving the entire cast. The author demonstrates particular skill in showing how marriage requires constant negotiation and mutual support, especially when strong personalities and competing loyalties come into play.
WORTH MENTIONING: This book challenged me. The structure of both the book and the relationship does not follow the typical romance story. I really enjoyed how Chase is pushing and remolding the typical romance story to fit this couple’s story.
CONNECTED BOOKS: MY INCONVENIENT DUKE is the third book in the Difficult Dukes series, though its events predate those of the first book. While the central romance reaches a complete resolution from beginning to end, readers will be better served by reading the other two books first as this story completely overlaps the stories of the other books and the background events may be puzzling and even frustrating without the knowledge of what is happening “off screen.”
STAR RATING: I give this book 4.5 stars.