Review: My Inconvenient Duke

Review: My Inconvenient DukeMy Inconvenient Duke (Difficult Dukes, #3) by Loretta Chase
Series: Difficult Dukes #3
on January 21, 2025
Genres: Historical
Goodreads

FINAL DECISION: Chase delivers a nuanced exploration of romance that extends and challenges the traditional romance narrative, examining the complexities of building a lasting partnership. The vibrant characters and authentic portrayal of married life create a beautiful addition to the series.

THE STORY: For years, the Duke of Blackwood has been known as the most sensible of Their Dis-Graces, the notorious trio of dukes whose escapades have scandalized London society. When Alice Ripley, sister to one of his fellow dukes, decides to enter the marriage market out of concern for her family’s future, Blackwood finds himself drawn into her orbit. His stated purpose may be protecting her from unsuitable suitors, but as Alice’s passionate pursuit of justice leads them into one situation after another, he discovers that maintaining his careful distance has become impossible. Their tale unfolds across two timelines, revealing both their path to marriage and the challenges they face in the year that follows.

OPINION: Chase tackles the ambitious task of telling a story that serves multiple narrative purposes while still delivering a satisfying romance. By structuring the novel across two distinct periods, she illuminates not just the thrill of falling in love but the day-to-day reality of living a married life.

The chemistry between Alice and Blackwood manifests in sharp-witted exchanges and unspoken understanding. Their shared history provides depth to their interactions, while their individual growth shows how two people can maintain their distinct personalities while building a life together. Alice stands out as a compelling protagonist whose convictions drive the narrative forward, while Blackwood’s gradual acknowledgment of his feelings unfolds with satisfying inevitability.

Though the novel’s unique structure creates occasional pacing issues, particularly in the transition between its two main sections, the rewards of this unconventional approach outweigh its drawbacks. Chase excels at period detail, weaving historical elements seamlessly into the narrative fabric without sacrificing momentum or emotional impact.

Memorable scenes abound, from intimate moments of realization to grander set pieces involving the entire cast. The author demonstrates particular skill in showing how marriage requires constant negotiation and mutual support, especially when strong personalities and competing loyalties come into play.

WORTH MENTIONING: This book challenged me. The structure of both the book and the relationship does not follow the typical romance story. I really enjoyed how Chase is pushing and remolding the typical romance story to fit this couple’s story.

CONNECTED BOOKS: MY INCONVENIENT DUKE is the third book in the Difficult Dukes series, though its events predate those of the first book. While the central romance reaches a complete resolution from beginning to end, readers will be better served by reading the other two books first as this story completely overlaps the stories of the other books and the background events may be puzzling and even frustrating without the knowledge of what is happening “off screen.”

STAR RATING: I give this book 4.5 stars.

Review: Ten Thing I Hate About the Duke

I received this book for free from Netgalley in order to prepare an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.


Review: Ten Thing I Hate About the DukeTen Things I Hate About the Duke (Difficult Dukes, #2) by Loretta Chase
Series: Difficult Dukes #2
Published by Avon on December 1, 2020
Genres: Historical
Pages: 400
Goodreads
four-half-stars

 

FINAL DECISION: Simply lovely romantic book. The hero and heroine move towards one another in this book without losing themselves. Wonderful read.

THE STORY: Cassandra Pomfret has known the Duke of Ashmont since she was a child. He was once her hero, and she had dreams of them together. But Ashmont disappointed her for years. He barely paid any attention to her and instead has spent his life being idle and wild. Cassandra has built a life for herself doing things of purpose. This life, however, is threatened by her father who refuses to allow Cassandra’s younger sister to have her season until Cassandra marries. Even that prospect, however, is put at risk by Ashmont’s presence, which seems to bring potential scandal in its wake.

OPINION: I really loved this story because Ashmont had to fight so hard for Cassandra. In the process, he grows and changes and finds a higher purpose in his life. There are external factors which push and pull these two characters together and apart, but this book is primarily the interactions between Ashmont and Cassandra. Her deep disappointment in him and his continued attempts to move towards her. I love a redemption story and Chase does an amazing job of making Ashmont’s journey a personal one.

Cassandra is a strong woman who is unwilling to place herself into the hands of Ashmont because she knows that heartache will be the only result — even if he is a duke. Her determination to tell him his failings and then his determination to make changes in his life animate this story.

The story is more romance than sex, and I loved that. I ended the book feeling that these characters had made extraordinary moves towards one another in a warm way.

WORTH MENTIONING: The book has a loose connection with the storyline of Shakespeare’s The Taming of Shrew.

CONNECTED BOOKS: TEN THINGS I HATE ABOUT THE DUKE is the second book in the Difficult Dukes series. The romance here is self-contained, and it is not necessary to have read the first book. Because this book overlaps with and continues from the events in the first book, however, reading the books in order gives more insight into the characters and their motivations.

STAR RATING: I give this book 4.5 stars.

NOTE: I received an eARC of this book via Netgalley. I was not required to write a review or to write a positive review. All opinions contained herein are my own.

 

four-half-stars

Review: A Duke in Shining Armor

Review: A Duke in Shining ArmorA Duke in Shining Armor (Difficult Dukes, #1) by Loretta Chase
Series: Difficult Dukes #1
Published by Avon on November 28th 2017
Genres: Historical
Pages: 400
Goodreads
four-half-stars

“She pushed open the window. ‘Adieu,’ she said. And climbed through, in a flutter of satin and lace.”

FINAL DECISION: I loved this book and the characters. Focused intensely on the hero and heroine, this book is about moments which change their lives, fate and chance, and making and living with their choices.

THE STORY: Hugh Philemon Ancaster, Duke of Ripley, has arrived in London for one of his best friend’s wedding. He is one of the trio of dukes known as Their Dis-Graces for their rakish and reckless behavior that had society hiding their innocent misses from them. Tasked with making sure the wedding goes off without a hitch, Ripley has a challenge when the brides slips out a window and disappears. Lady Olympia Hightower is in a position that women envy. Seven years the Most Boring Girl of the Season until she became engaged to one of the Dis-Graces. On the eve of her wedding, she has second thoughts and fueled by too much alcohol she makes a run for it.  Ripley is determined to protect Olympia on her run and intends on returning her to his friend — until he realizes he can’t.

OPINION: I have to admit that while I read all kinds of books and certainly all kinds of romance books, what I read for is relationship and characters. The external drama in this book is small — a woman engaged to one man falls for his best friend. What makes this book extra special is the exploration of how these two characters fall in love and deal with their love and their guilt.

The relationship and dialogue between Ripley and Olympia sparkles with humor and great emotion. The exploration of fate and missed chances and grabbing onto what one wants gave this story depth. It is would incredibly easy to formulate the story of the fiance who is unworthy or a liar or who doesn’t really care. Chase doesn’t take the easy route. These two feel intense guilt and really wonder if they had missed their chance.  Choices are not always easy or clear. There is a real call to action — what will you regret now, what will you regret forever?

There is such a connection between Ripley and Olympia — humor, exasperation, understanding, lust, anger. They days they spend together and the intensity of their experience brings them to love. Usually romances that only last days are difficult to understand. This book works beautifully in that sense. This is not insta-love but a mutual recognition of something more that is built upon years of awareness combined with an intense period of interaction.

There are some laugh out funny scenes in this book — including an indoor race that might be my favorite I’ve read this year. The intensity, humor and deep emotion of this book will stay with me for a long time.

WORTH MENTIONING: Introduced in this book, there are two other couples and the cast off Duke of Ashmont whose stories should be explored in this series.

CONNECTED BOOKS: A DUKE IN SHINING ARMOR is the first book in the Difficult Dukes series.

STAR RATING: I give this book 5 stars.

NOTE: I received an ARC of this book via Edelweiss in order to provide a review. I was not required to write a review or to write a positive review. All opinions contained herein are my own.

four-half-stars